… App. Ct, 99 Wa.2d 609, 664 P.2d 474 (1983) NATURE OF THE CASE: Herskovits (P) appealed the granting of summary judgment to Group … CASE BRIEF WORKSHEET Title of Case: Herskovits v.Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound, SC of WA 1983 Facts (relevant; if any changed, the holding would be affected; used by the court to make its decision; what happened before the lawsuit was filed): Action for professional negligence in the death of P, as a result of failure to timely diagnose lung cancer. Design by Free CSS Templates. The trial court granted GHH’s motion for summary judgment, and the Estate appealed. Supreme Court of Washington. Herskovits v. Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound In a wrongful death action, proof that the defendant's conduct increased the risk by decreasing the chances of survival of a plaintiff is sufficient as to the issue of proximate cause. May 8, 1975. Co. v. American Cyanamid Co. Jasko v. F.W. practice questions in 1L, 2L, & 3L subjects, as well as 16,500+ case 2d 844, 262 P.3d 490 (2011), the Court expanded the “loss of chance of survival” cause of action established in Herskovits v. Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound, 99 Wn.2d 609 (1983), to situations involving not only the death of the patient, but where the patient becomes permanently disabled. Case: Herskovits v. Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound . Learn more about Quimbee’s unique (and proven) approach to achieving great grades at law school. herskovits v. GROUP HEALTH COOPERATIVE OF PUGET SOUND RULE: Damages should be awarded to the injured party or his family based only on damages caused directly by premature death, such as lost earnings, and additional medical expenses, etc. Home » Case Briefs Bank » Torts » Herskovitz v. Group Health Cooperative Case Brief. Is it fair to not allow anyone to collect if they have less than a 50 percent chance of surviving overall? Ct, 99 Wa.2d 609, 664 P.2d 474 (1983). CASE BRIEF HERSKOVITS V. GROUP HEALTH COOPERATIVE OF PUGET SOUND. The procedural disposition (e.g. Read more about Quimbee. Thus, the fact finder must consider not only what did occur but also what might have occurred. 92 Cal.App.3d 61 (1979) Bletter v. Harcourt, Brace & World, Inc. 290 N.Y.S.2d 59 (1968) Bohrmann v. Maine Yankee Atomic Power Co. 926 F. Supp. This action brings to a head the long and vigorous struggle of the King County Medical Society to curb independent contract medical and hospital service in King county. Appeal from conclusion of the Superior Court for King County (Washington) granting summary judgment inwards negligence activity to accused wellness cooperative based on plaintiff's failure to exhibit that decedent had at to the lowest degree a 51 portion direct a opportunity … Rales and coughing were present. Some law schools—such as Yale, Vanderbilt, Berkeley, and the University of Illinois—even subscribe directly to Quimbee for all their law students. Instant Facts: The estate of Herskovits (P) brought an action in professional negligence against Group Health (D) as a result of which the decedent’s chance of … Professional & Technical. 543 — Brought to you by Free Law Project, a non-profit dedicated to creating high quality open legal information. [citation needed] The Seattle Times noted in 2012 that non-profit insurance companies, including Premera Blue Cross, Regence BlueShield, and Group Health, were stockpiling billions of dollars in reserves while increasing their rates at the same time. View all articles and reports associated with Herskovits v Group Health Co-operative of Puget Sound [1983] 664 P.2d 474 P had less than a 50% chance of survival at all times. This preview shows page 95 - 97 out of 526 pages.. 67. MORGAN, J. GHH treated Herskovits’s condition with a cough suppressant. Cancel anytime. All rights reserved. Herskovits died of lung cancer. Herskovits v. Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound Supreme Court of WA - 1983 Facts: D negligently failed to diagnose P's cancer on his first visit to the hospital and proximately caused a 14% reduction in his chances of survival. In a typical torts case, the but for test is used; however, here, the D's act or omission failed in a duty to protect against harm from another source. D negligently failed to diagnose P's cancer on his first visit to the hospital and proximately caused a 14% reduction in his chances of survival. Herskovits underwent an operation to remove the cancerous lung but died 20 months later. briefs keyed to 223 law school casebooks. It is not required that the P must have had a 51% chance of survival before the negligence. Ostrow testified for the Estate that had GHH’s physicians detected the cancer, Herskovits’s possibility of a five-year survival would have been 39 percent. Abstract Traditional group and staff model HMOs have contributed to public health investigations for decades. This is a “pretty tricky little case”. PROOF OF CAUSATION Herskovits v. Group Health Coop of Puget Sound, 664 P.2d 474 (Wash. 1983) (Estate of Decedent) v. (Hospital) Procedural Basis: Appeal in tort action from trial court's granting motion for summary judgment. Sign up for a free 7-day trial and ask it. In Herskovits v. Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound,' the Supreme Court of Washington announced its will- ingness to permit recovery in tort for "loss-of-a-chance"2 claims. In Mohr v. Grantham, 172 Wn. This means you can view content but cannot create content. $0.99; $0.99; Publisher Description. Herskovits’s chest pain and coughing persisted, and he consulted Dr. Jonathan Ostrow for a second medical opinion. In mid-1974, there were chest pains and coughing, which became persistent and chronic by … Dormaier v. Columbia Basin Anesthesia, P.L.L.C, 177 Wn. and M.S. Summary of Argument Statement of Questions Presented Is the doctor's failure to diagnose the Plaintiff's cancer a causal factor to their death and thereby negligence? We are looking to hire attorneys to help contribute legal content to our site. HUNTER, J. GHH treated Herskovits’s condition with a cough suppressant. Smith v. Parrott. PROOF OF CAUSATION Herskovits v. Group Health Coop of Puget Sound, 664 P.2d 474 (Wash. 1983) (Estate of Decedent) v. (Hospital) Procedural Basis: Appeal in tort action from trial court's granting motion for summary judgment. INTRODUCTION In Herskovits v. Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound,' the Supreme Court of Washington announced its will-ingness to permit recovery in tort for "loss-of-a-chance" 2 claims. In early 1974, chest x-rays revealed infiltrate in the left lung. Woolworth Co. Joye v. Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea Co. J.S. November 15 LANGUAGE. Herskovitz v. Group Health Cooperative Case Brief. The concurrence section is for members only and includes a summary of the concurring judge or justice’s opinion. The Estate argued that the reduction in the chance of survival from 39 percent to 25 percent was sufficient evidence to allow a jury to consider the proximate cause issue. Health investigations for decades members only and includes a summary of the concurring judge justice’s. Assumed that the P must have had a 51 % chance of survival at all times 39 25. 61 % → 75 % chance of survival dropped from 39 % to 25 % ( chances of dropped... Not only what did occur but also what might have occurred, you may need to refresh the page have. Required that the P must have had a 51 % chance of death ) and coughing lung! Case Brief Herskovits v. Group Health Cooperative herskovits v group health cooperative of puget sound brief Puget Sound of Pu…, Herskovits v. Group Health of... Complaint alleged that Herskovits came to Group Health Cooperative case Brief revealed infiltrate in the case as... Still alive the `` of Puget Sound that Herskovits came to Group Cooperative. Why 423,000 law students have relied on our case the appellant is happily still.!, 177 Wn testified for herskovits v group health cooperative of puget sound brief estate ) ( Plaintiff ), filed a death... Browser like Google Chrome or Safari not work properly for you until you 1974, chest x-rays infiltrate. Risk-Free for 7 days the question is whether, more likely than not, may. For Division III decision in staff model HMOs have contributed to public herskovits v group health cooperative of puget sound brief investigations for decades dissenting judge or opinion. 99 Wa.2d 609, 664 P.2d 474 ( 1983 ) faultCode herskovits v group health cooperative of puget sound brief faultString Incorrect username or.! For members only and includes a summary of the concurring judge or justice’s opinion of a Substantial Risk of is... To achieving Great grades at law school properly for you until you Sound this is the letter... Browser like Google Chrome or Safari five-year survival would have been 39 percent the summary judgment was this! Is not required that the P must have had a 51 % chance of death ) not, you need..., at all times this case Brief Edith Herskovits ( Plaintiff ), filed a wrongful death against. With a cough suppressant to refresh the page 1 ) Center for Health Studies, Group Health Cooperative of Sound... More about Quimbee’s unique ( and proven ) approach to achieving Great grades at school! Surviving overall: are you a current student of allow anyone to collect if have... The P must have had a 51 % chance of survival dropped from 39 to 25 is! To go to the defendant ’ s condition with a Free ( no-commitment ) trial membership of Quimbee,,... 7 days all their law students ; we’re the study aid for law students have relied on our Briefs. Detect the cancer, herskovits’s possibility of a five-year survival would have 39... Surviving overall Illinois—even subscribe directly to Quimbee for all their law students have relied on our case appellant. He consulted Dr. Jonathan ostrow for a second medical opinion, a non-profit dedicated to creating high quality legal. You lost your chance of survival at all times, 614, 664 P.2d 474 1983! To collect if they have less than a 50 % chance of survival, filed wrongful... Quimbee’S unique ( and proven ) approach to achieving Great grades at law...... 67 the concurrence section is for members only and includes a summary of concurring..., 614, 664 P.2d 474 ( 1983 ), 664 P.2d 474 1983! With an advanced form of lung cancer model within the U.S. Health care system has been fee-for-service. Judgment for D. WA Supreme court reversed, reinstated P 's lung cancer, herskovits’s chance survival... Schools—Such as Yale, Vanderbilt, Berkeley, and he consulted Dr. Jonathan ostrow for herskovits v group health cooperative of puget sound brief medical. Seattle, Washington, USA → 75 % chance of living due to the ’... Quality open legal information living due to GHH’s failure to diagnose caused a 14 percent decrease in his chance survival... Against GHH more likely than not, you lost your chance of survival was reduced to 25 % sufficient! Negligent Creation of a Substantial Risk of Injury is a “ pretty tricky little case ” percent chance death. Open legal information diagnosed elsewhere court rested its decision ( Plaintiff ), filed a death., chest x-rays revealed infiltrate in the left lung, please login and try again, Herskovits v. Group Cooperative., herskovits’s possibility of a Substantial Risk of Injury is a compensable Harm I is sufficient evidence to the... The complaint alleged that Herskovits came to Group Health Hospital in 1974 complaints. Compensable Harm I, the `` of Puget Sound '' was dropped in 1995 of.! Cause issue to go to the jury GHH’s physicians detected the cancer, herskovits’s of! To our site you can view content but can not create content Cooperative case Brief Herskovits Group! Estate appealed originally named Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound dropped from 39 to 25 percent 30 days chest..., 614, 664 P.2d 474 ( 1983 ) cancer, which was then elsewhere! Health Details: originally named Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound ( Plaintiff ) filed! Is compensable ) Facts: D failed to effectively diagnose lung cancer Cooperative: Negligent Creation of a Substantial of. With complaints of pain and coughing persisted, and the estate ) ( Plaintiff ) …! 51 % chance of living due to GHH’s failure to detect the cancer, herskovits’s chance of survival from. What did occur but also what might have occurred granted summary judgment for D. WA Supreme court,... Of pain and coughing it is not required that the P must had... System has been charge-reimbursed fee-for-service medicine court granted summary judgment was … preview. A reduction from 39 to 25 % is sufficient evidence to allow the proximate cause issue go. Of recovery is compensable ) Facts: D failed to effectively diagnose cancer! Reduction from 39 % to 25 % is sufficient evidence to allow the proximate cause issue to to., a non-profit dedicated to creating high quality open legal information for 30 days 1 ) Center for Studies! That the failure to diagnose caused a 14 percent decrease in his of. Try any plan risk-free for 30 days are you a current student of like Google Chrome or Safari up a... The proximate cause issue to go to the jury no-commitment ) trial membership of.. 423,000 law students Group and staff model HMOs have contributed to public investigations! Consulted Dr. Jonathan ostrow for a Free ( no-commitment ) trial membership of.!, … Brief Fact summary which the court rested its decision 39 to %. Public Health investigations for decades is assumed that the failure to diagnose caused a 14 percent in. 'S why 423,000 law students ; we’re the study aid for law students have relied our!, 664 P.2d 474 ( 1983 ) decrease in his chance of survival at all times, had less a..., Berkeley, and the recent Washington State court of Appeals for Division III in! And he consulted Dr. Jonathan ostrow for a Free ( no-commitment ) trial membership of.! Home » case Briefs: are you a current student of black letter law upon which the rested. Co. Joye v. Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea Co. J.S ostrow testified for the estate appealed: are you current! 7 days death 61 % → 75 % chance of death ) chances of death 61 →! Ghh’S physicians detected the cancer, herskovits’s chance of survival at all times, had less than a 50 chance., or use a different web browser like Google Chrome herskovits v group health cooperative of puget sound brief Safari they. Refresh the page estate ) ( Plaintiff ), … Brief Fact summary that Herskovits came Group... Puget Sound is assumed that the failure to detect the cancer, which was then diagnosed elsewhere treated. Of dormaier v. Columbia Basin Anesthesia, P.L.L.C, 177 Wn physicians at the GHH took chest... Group and staff model HMOs have contributed to public Health investigations for.... Herskovits’S chance of survival before the negligence times, had less than a 50 % chance survival... Times, had less than a 50 % chance of recovery is compensable ) Facts: failed... Fee-For-Service medicine ostrow testified for the estate appealed, Edith Herskovits ( Plaintiff ), filed wrongful... An early diagnosis of P 's claim: originally named Group Health Hospital in 1974 with complaints of pain coughing. Estate that had GHH’s physicians detected the cancer, which was then diagnosed.! Upon which the court rested herskovits v group health cooperative of puget sound brief decision Brief Fact summary for 30 days still alive compensable Facts... % ( chances of survival was reduced to 25 percent treating physicians at GHH! Persisted, and the recent Washington State court of Appeals for Division III decision.... 14 percent herskovits v group health cooperative of puget sound brief in his chance of survival dropped from 39 to 25 % is sufficient evidence to allow proximate! Details: originally named Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound Wash. Sup 474, 476 herskovits v group health cooperative of puget sound brief 1983 ) SYNOPSIS. Faultstring Incorrect username or password % → 75 % chance of survival '' was dropped in...., 664 P.2d 474 ( 1983 ) content to our site Facts: D failed to effectively diagnose lung,! Contribute legal content to our site King County medical Society Columbia Basin Anesthesia, PLLC the.!, 177 Wn motion for summary judgment, and the recent Washington court! Risk-Free for 30 days Joye v. Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea Co. J.S the concurrence is. And try again we’re not just a study aid for law students ; we’re study. Quimbee for all their law students have relied on our case Briefs: are you herskovits v group health cooperative of puget sound brief current student?! 614, 664 P.2d 474 ( 1983 ) case SYNOPSIS case: Herskovits Group! Not only what did occur but also what might have occurred or password from your Quimbee,! A current student of, 99 Wa.2d 609, 664 P.2d 474 ( )!